Was Seth Ireland Failed By a Broken System?

Tools

By Preston Phillips

3-million reports of child abuse are made every year in the United States, and experts estimate that the actual number of incidents of abuse is 3 times greater than reported.

Everyday, 4 children die as a result of child abuse.

After the tragic death of Seth Ireland, many are now looking for ways to better protect kids, and ways to fix what they call a broken system.

Its something, one family law critic out of San Diego says she's been pushing for, for years.

In this interview conducted Wednesday afternoon with Joseph Hudson, the father of murdered 10-year-old Seth Ireland, Hudson blames police, the courts and child protective services for failing to protect his son, from the man who's accused of beating him to death, Lebaron Vaughn, the mother's live-in boyfriend.

Joseph Hudson, Victim’s Father: “My son slipped through the cracks. He was not protected like he should have been."

But Catherine Huerta, who oversees the county's child protective services, says they did the best they could.

Catherine Huerta, Department of Children and Family Services: "Am I confident my social worker was working the case? Was she investigating to the best of her ability? Yes she was."

Since August of 2008 Hudson had been involved in a bitter custody battle over his son.

But did Seth Ireland really slip through the cracks, or is it that our system was so broken, little Seth never fared a chance?

Bonnie Russell, familylawcourts.com: "Ffalling through the cracks means the system is working fine. The system is not working fine, except for people who are getting paychecks in the system. It benefits the workers, not the children who are presented to the workers."

Bonnie Russell started the website, familylawcourts.com back in 2001, when she began noticing problems in the judicial system.

Russell is considered an expert, she says, in the field of how family court doesn't work and why, and parental alienation.

Russell: "You want the judge to speak directly to the child, but the judge doesn't want to do that, so they order experts."

Experts, who she says many times, aren't professionally trained to evaluate the mental state of a child.

Because of this she says, children who are being abused, many times, end up back with the abuser themselves.

She says for this reason alone, children must be given a voice in the courtroom.

Russell: "A child is a credible source, but that stops the litigation train if the child speaks up. Its not that the children are slipping through the cracks, they're the marketing tool. Parents are the fuel source and the top of it is the child."

At the end of August, CPS launched a child abuse investigation and although they received numerous referrals of abuse, up until Seth Ireland was killed, they say they were never able to gather any conclusive, physical evidence that he was being abused.

For this reason, Seth could not legally be removed from the home.

Family law critic, Bonnie Russell says, in addition to children being given a voice in the courtroom, immunity should be taken away from social workers, so they themselves can be held responsible in a court of law for any mistakes they've made.

For Preston Phillips’ full story, click on the video link above.

For Preston Phillips' bio click here.

Sunday, Aug 9 at 6:45 PM Judy wrote ...

What a coincidence. CPS yet again fails to protect. Yet how many false accusations result in wrongful removal of children from their good parents? Too many. CPS needs to be abolished - they are corrupt. Even cursory research demonstrates that their corruption is widespread and deep.

Thursday, Jun 25 at 6:16 AM Victor wrote ...

The Problem is NOT the CPS nor it is the solution. In order to fix the problem, one have to find the root cause of the problem. All these horible stories. WHAT IS THE COMMON DENOMINATOR? Lustfull Nation. We need GOD NOT CPS. We have spent over a million dollars inventing a pen that would write in an outer space, and Russians still use a pensil. Lets Not waste millions of dollars on improving CPS (that will only make things worse), but REALIZE THAT THIS IS HOW LIFE IS WITHOUT GOD.

Wednesday, Apr 22 at 5:56 PM DESPERATE PARENT wrote ...

My sons biological father had his kids from his previous relathionship taken away by CPS for physical abuse.In 2003 CPS opened an investigation against him and he disappeared so CPS closed the investigation. Now after almost 6 years he reappeared and wants custody of the child we have together. My son does not know this man but the judge refused to terminate his rights! CPS claims they can not reopen the 2003 case, I would have to start a new case after he starts beating my child.

Friday, Apr 17 at 12:54 AM Bonnie wrote ...

Don't expect the CJP to address the judicial rulings. But the public can make a difference. See www.USAjudges.com

Wednesday, Jan 28 at 3:04 PM Annie wrote ...

The problem is us. The solution is us, too. So make a report on good and bad judges at USAjudges.com and pay it forward. Help someone else out.

Friday, Jan 23 at 1:23 AM Jackie wrote ...

Lets see, lets all do drugs and let our children catch us then let the child go into chambers and tell the judge and then when we go take a drug test lets sneak fake urine in and get caught. then when we do take the test and fail it and the judge sees it so what because the judge will just do nothing about it and make the child go to visit anyway without supervised visits.then lets drive around with the child and an open beer between our legs or drunk on a boat cuz the judge dont care ask my kid

Tuesday, Jan 20 at 6:21 PM Marcelo wrote ...

Wow... I believe in what CPS stands for protect the children, however, I dont think it works like its ment to work. I think Seth was let down not only by the system but buy those who brought him to this world and all of us who sit and talk and do nothing. I believe we need better traind CPS workers with less case loads so they can really help these kids who we as parents are letting down. Just like some kids have been let down some have been saved by that system that needs to be worked on.

Tuesday, Jan 13 at 1:28 PM Myshel wrote ...

PLEASE WRITE THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS HALL OF RECORD 2281 TULARE ST ROOM 301 FRESNO CA 93721 TO COMPLAINED ABOUT CPS

Monday, Jan 12 at 12:06 PM Joyce Murphy wrote ...

After six years of trying every way possible to protect my child, she is with me only because her father was finally arrested for repeat sexual molestation of minors under the age of 14. One child came forward with "physical evidence" - one can only despair over what that means. How many children and their families have been destroyed by the pedophiles and the courts who protect the monsters? Each time I tried to get ayone to listen, the molester's rights superceded anyone else's.

Monday, Jan 12 at 3:56 AM Patrick wrote ...

Someone needs to really see who works in the CPS and Adult Services! My Mother In Law Passed Away after we reported abuse from her husband! She was ill and could not do for herself. We fougt to bring her home with us but the social worker still let her husbund have total control. He got his wish she passed on. ALL WE GOT WAS AN IM SORRY, WE NEVER GOT A CHANCE TO FOLLOW UP ON THIS. These poor children need the help of people with a heart not the DEVIL IN DISQUISE, who's only concern is the money!

Sunday, Jan 11 at 7:39 PM Myshel Jewel wrote ...

Yeah...he was failed by those lazy, lazy Social Workers. For the life of me why go to school to get your BA and MSW? Too not do the job. I do not understand. They should start prosecution. Can you believe that both of those adults who killed pleaded not guilty? Now watch they give them an option in sentencing. I am getting ready to rally up the troops and you can beleive he is going to be sentence to death!

Sunday, Jan 11 at 1:57 AM Isabel wrote ...

I have called CPS in the past due to child neglect and abuse that my then minor children and I witnessed by our neighbor almost daily some years ago. When I did call CPS, they were asking for me to do my own investigation and hand it over "on a platter". CPS told me they don't have time to investigate unless we have the info they need. My family feel the system let that little boy and many like down. Seth had to die and CPS has the same excuses for why they failed our children again! Yeah sure

Friday, Jan 9 at 8:29 PM Peter wrote ...

The judge and CPS workers involved in this case should also be charged in this case

Friday, Jan 9 at 6:43 PM Julia Colloton wrote ...

My daughters claimed sexual and physical abuse? Guess where Steve Nordquist placed them for custody after this allegation? Their father? Do we have pedophiles and child abusers under the robes? And the Chief Judges step in to protect these apathetic judges

Friday, Jan 9 at 1:47 PM Michelle wrote ...

It did fail him.... and it fail many others like him....

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

KSEE 24 NEWS and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More Good Stuff

Advertisement
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
Icon
Current Temp 49.0 °F
Mostly Cloudy
Wind : Calm
Humidity : 93 %
Pressure : 1022.0 mb
More Weather

On Demand

Stock Quotes

What's On TonightFull Schedule

8:00
Minute to Win It
9:00
Celebrity Apprentice
Local Business Dir

Valley Viewpoint Poll

What makes you happy?

  • Money
  • Family
  • Health
  • Job
  • KSEE 24 News @ 7