Lawyer and friends react to police beating video

Tools

By Preston Phillips

The Fresno Police Department launches an internal investigation after a video, obtained exclusively by KSEE 24 News, shows two officers beating a homeless man during an arrest.

Warning: this video may be disturbing to some viewers.

This is the video responsible for launching an internal investigation into these two Fresno Police officers, seen here repeatedly punching 52-year-old Glen Beaty, a homeless man, who police say resisted arrest.

Amateur Videographer: "I don't think anybody should be beat like that, they don't beat dogs and let you get away with it."

The man who handed the video to KSEE 24 news on Tuesday morning, says he captured it with his video camera, because he said what he was witnessing at the time, just didn't make sense...

Friends of Beaty say they too, find it hard to believe.

Friend of Beaty: "Knowing the guy and being here as long as I’ve been here, I don’t think he would do anything to upset an officer that bad."

Tuesday night, we played the video for Criminal Defense Attorney, Daniel Bacon, who called the video disturbing and the police officer's behavior, inexcusable.

Bacon said he believes that in this particular case, Beaty not only has a valid defense, but perhaps a meritorious lawsuit.

Daniel bacon, Attorney at Law: "These incidents occur more than the public wants to believe they do, and it's only through things like this that people will actually see and their eyes will tell them what has happened. Otherwise it's just a homeless man saying he was brutalized by the police and that you know and a dollar will get you a cup of coffee."

But Fresno Police Chief Jerry Dyer says Glen Beaty is a man with a proven history of violence... Before Monday’s arrest, 3 prior law enforcement contacts, including resisting arrest and injuring a sheriff's deputy.

Dyer says Beaty was ultimately arrested Monday on a felony warrant.

The police chief says until a full investigation, into the incident is complete he can't form any opinions.

Adding what may seem disturbing to most on the surface, may not be considered an excessive use of force in the end.

Because of what he says, detailed police reports state happened, leading up to Beaty's arrest.

Jerry Dyer, Fresno Police Chief: "One of the officers was punched by the suspect in the arm. The officer had his badge ripped off of his shirt. There was also an attempt to jab the officer in the arm with a pen that the suspect had taken from the officer’s shirt.”

Police Chief Jerry Dyer says both officers involved in the arrest of Beaty have been placed on limited duty, pending an internal investigation.

Chief Dyer says the officers chose not to "taze" Beaty because he was wearing a heavy jacket at the time, adding it would not have produced the desired outcome.

The investigation into the incident is already gaining nationwide attention.

For Preston Phillips’ full story, click on the video link above.

Click here for Preston Phillips' bio

Tuesday, Jun 16 at 12:18 PM johnnie23128@yahoo.com wrote ...

i commented once but i just have to say that i was beat up while there was kids around my daughter is just one of them along with others, im poor and cant fight back, but to me any cop that beats anyone should pay double the price and be fired,they are punk thugs.

Tuesday, Jun 16 at 12:11 PM johnnie thorne wrote ...

i was beat up by 3 officers so i know how it feels,and anyone who beleives these officers were in the right need beat to, may they will see how it feels that was a crime and they need punished

Saturday, Feb 14 at 1:05 PM lawguy35 wrote ...

ATTENTION: officers seem to think they are all above the law, which this incident speaks for its self. i have one other thing about being above the law, i have noticed many officers in many different cities talking on cell phones while driving. if we cant do this they should neither maybe well start filming this to.

Friday, Feb 13 at 9:09 PM Nicole T. wrote ...

The officers got out of hand with this one, as they do on most occasions. They have handcuffs, that's more than enough for restraining a person who is supposedly a threat, I see no need for fists to fly. I guess it's just a power trip on their part, being the big ol' officer on duty and all. Good thing no names were mentioned, oh, except for the oh so alarming homeless man, Glen Beaty. And poor officer no-name, broke a pinky, better stay off duty for some time now...

Friday, Feb 13 at 9:07 PM aloha wrote ...

This is CRAZY! I take martial arts, and those cops were big enough to take me out in 2 seconds without the punches...that is what they are "supposed" learn as an officer. Two jerks against one person could have easily subdued that man without the violence!

Friday, Feb 13 at 12:30 PM justice for all wrote ...

ATTENTION: everyone needs to have a camera in hand for reasons just like this. so lets all go get a video camera and start filming your local police. it is a free country and no one can take it from you. we have rights.

Friday, Feb 13 at 11:34 AM Anon wrote ...

I think bottom line is someone tore my shirt and jabbed me with a pen, I would not be authorized to hold them down and punch them repeatedly in the head. I would be told that I was no longer defending myself at that point in time. There's no excuse for this sort of behavior from a public servant.

Friday, Feb 13 at 3:19 AM LizzieC wrote ...

For all of you who say we don't know what happened before the video - it does not matter! It is not protocol to repeatedly punch someone in the face! There is a right way to restrain someone! They are just beating the man. The police chief should resign for defending them and for promoting their lame story. I have a family member and a neighbor who are officers. They have dignity, something these officers do not have.

Friday, Feb 13 at 1:49 AM Fresno Bob wrote ...

That is so sad they beat that guy. It just goes to show you its not smart to get between a cop and his donuts

Thursday, Feb 12 at 7:49 AM Concerned wrote ...

The taxpayers should not be held liable for these two officers conduct. Let them personally pay for it or their union that allows this sort of behavior.

Thursday, Feb 12 at 7:49 AM Anonymous wrote ...

What they don't show in the video is what happened before the man was on the ground. Not only did he attack the officers, but he also has a history of this. For those of you that are defending this tax dollar-consuming lowlife of a person and calling this brutality, you need to consider the fact that 99% of homeless people are on drugs and the chance that he even noticed that he was getting punched is very low.

Thursday, Feb 12 at 4:18 AM citizen wrote ...

Citzens of fresno beware, before defending of a known violent wanted felon, who has shown a history of violence towards officers.failing to comply to verbal cammands. he did not give up by laying down. Given our every day heroes no option, but to use force to affect an arrest, and or overcome resitance. This man(Homeless)is a large male,drunk and abviously not compliying. Officers make split second dicessions, that others will take years to critique. Thank You FPD for keeping us safe

Thursday, Feb 12 at 3:23 AM F's Wife wrote ...

Although I believe that these two officers used excessive force, we all must restrain from jumping to conclusions. Just as every other person that is convicted of a crime is innocent until proven guilty - these two officers are no different! And for everyone who is saying they are scared of cops and don't trust them - then don't call 911 when your getting robbed, beat up, burglarized, and so on. Keep in mind that there are always a few bad apples in every batch! Don't characterize every officer!

Thursday, Feb 12 at 3:04 AM Dana1 wrote ...

Hard to see why they could not have handcuffed the man. Especially since he was already face down in the dirt. Situations such as these are good reasons for our having the FBI. Punching an already downed man? Stand tall feds. You still have some standards

Thursday, Feb 12 at 2:46 AM Dave wrote ...

If you resist arrest in any way- and this video only shows what happened AFTER he resisted- you can expect a beating. Don't want a beating? Do what the officers tell you- don't punch them, kick them or try stab them with things.

Thursday, Feb 12 at 1:43 AM Mr. JEW wrote ...

Mr."H" is full of it the officer on the right has no badge. pause your video and look hard or go to an optomitrist. "Innocent until proven Guilty" that's the way the legal system is set up.

Thursday, Feb 12 at 12:16 AM Steve Fox wrote ...

It will cost the taxpayers even more money. Right after they get done bailing out Wall Street they will have to pay for these police officers jury verdict. I read the best websites for my blog, http://unitedstatesvicepresident.com and this is the third officer beating in six months. They just ruined their careers.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 11:14 PM Get Real wrote ...

In Defense of PD, there is no way anyone can look at that tape and say that man was resisting. Hell! he was even putting up his hands or anything to avoid being punched. He was being held by one cop while the other was punching him! Plain and simple. Well, now we know where those two teens in Tennesse got it from to take a homeless woman and throw her in the river and drown her. How can we expect more from the average citizens and especially our young when our cops are behaving so badly?

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 11:14 PM Liam wrote ...

The use of force continuem mandates that application of force focus on nerve bundles which effect limb control in order to gain willful/pain compliance. No nerve bundles in the face control limb control. Inadequate LE personalities...

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 10:46 PM Mr. H wrote ...

I think the police chief is full of it. In the video you can see both officers have their badges on their shirts, yet, the chief said the homeless man tore one off. this is a drunk homeless man on the ground, being punched in the face, but yet he's able to allegedly inflict harm or resist arrest. sounds like a cover up

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 8:14 PM Mr. L wrote ...

It seems to me that the Fresno Police Dept is always doing something that the citizens are arguing against. People are being killed, beaten up, and even robbed by the Police. The Badge has to much power. I would like to qoute Uncle Ben from the SpiderMan movie "With Great Power comes great Responsibility". Each police officer should go through better psyc test to see which are more prone to violence. the Fresno Police honestly scare me. They are suppossed to protect and serve not maim and kill.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 7:37 PM Bert wrote ...

I'm embarrassed to tell people I'm from Fresno anymore. I watched the raw video and WOW! Let's see, Fresno cops are stealing cars and beating up on restrained homeless people, what's next? I can't wait! All I can say is that the media is going to eat this one up.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 7:32 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Good Job Fresno PD !! I want to wish those guys good luck on a new career.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 7:08 PM V Diane Corbin wrote ...

Maybe we should start at the top (Dist. Attny who refuses to file charges at police from another incident)Who is she covering for? And how long does Dyer think he can "make all the bad go away?" How far are his hands covered with dirt? Same for the union. I suggest that we look for whole new group of police - if there is such a thing as decent police.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 5:47 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I don't know if anyone has pointed this out yet, but if you notice, the officer hitting the man is wearing gloves, where the other officer isn't. Why would the officer that is doing the holding choose not to wear gloves?

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 5:46 PM scott morley wrote ...

They're all rednecks out there in Fresno anyway. Let them do whatever they want to each other.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 5:36 PM VeridicalOne wrote ...

Two police officers holding one man to the ground seemed to be working quite well. There was no reason to punch the man in the face. No one started out homeless. Maybe that cop will have the opportunity to experience that one day.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 5:34 PM Mike wrote ...

This is another engagement in the War on the American Citizen... http://truthalert.net/Police%20Militarization%20and%20the%20War%20on%20the%20American%20Citizen.htm

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 5:30 PM BOB wrote ...

I THOUGHT FRESNO PD WAS TO PROTECT US NOT BEAT US. THAT SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED. I HOPE THOSE COPS GET WHAT THEY DESERVE, BY GOING TO PRISON. HOW WOULD THEY LIKE IT IF THEY WERE THE VICTIM.THATS NOT RIGHT AT ALL.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 5:11 PM Liberty wrote ...

Welcome people to the POLICE STATE. This is just a preview of whats to come. Arm yourselves with video cameras and let the police now youre watching. You do have the right to observe. If theyre doing nothing wrong they wont object. Take back your FREEDOM! The true Patriots are the people fighting for freedom not the ones taking it from you.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 4:38 PM GApoliceoff. wrote ...

Shame on you. Not one punch, but several... Fresno Police, you need to see a counselor and look for another job. What example are you setting? THEN YOU LOOK AROUND TO SEE IF ANYONE WAS WATCHING!!!

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 4:05 PM In Defense of PD wrote ...

If people would look at the demeanor of Beaty they would see that he IS resisting the officers. he's pushing back, refusing to be cuffed, pulling them down to the ground with him as he resists. This is a man with a history of violence to police. I'm sure they all know him by name, and he was probalby being verbally abusive as well. You couldn't pay me enough to be a cop, especially when most of society is so ignorant that they side with the criminals. Keep on keeping Fresno safe. Go FPD.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 3:45 PM A POLICE OFFICER wrote ...

These comments are disturbing... a number of you are forming an opinion without seeing the whole incident and knowing everything that occurred. I suggest you watch the whole uncut raw video, not the edited version (dramatic version). I would also wait to hear the whole story. The chief would be stupid to blast his officers and pass judgement to the media before he knows the whole story from reports. There is a process called an INVESTIGATION that needs to be completed.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 3:39 PM Will wrote ...

Wow! Unbelievable. I'm speachless. What ever happened to humanity? What ever happened to humanity? What ever happened to humanity?

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 3:36 PM Anonymous wrote ...

This is not police brutality! It is simply a person who chose to break the law and assault the officers. He could have submitted at any time. Maybe if he had a joband was not drinking, using drugs he would not he had to go through this. He is a drain on the economy and now people want to feel sorry for him; give me a break how about feeling sorry for everyone who is paying for his monthly SSI check and now his bills in Jail. This is the problem with this liberal welfare state.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 3:18 PM heckandarn wrote ...

Chief Dyer, you need a new job! Fresno has had enough of your exceptionally poor leadership. Resign now!

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 3:01 PM JERRY wrote ...

FRESNO POLICE DEPT, SHAME ON YOU.... YOUR OUT OF CONTROL!! AGAIN. I'AM GLADE YOU GUYS GOT CAUGHT ON TAPE..THIS WILL HELP FRESNO, WITH IT'S BUDGET PROBLEMS...

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 2:55 PM Doug wrote ...

What happened before the video was taken? Officers have a right to protect themselves and to do what is necessary to get a violent person to comply. Don't judge until all the details are provided.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 2:52 PM Beckola wrote ...

It's interesting that the PO took a look around before he gave the guy one more punch for good measure! Chief Cyers comments sadly show that the FPD believes they are untouchable. Just another reason for an independant Police auditor

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 2:50 PM Sergyi Metok wrote ...

Another shameless police chief who is not taking responsibility for the actions of his subordinates. Hopefully a criminal attorney will litigate this situation. Since the man was on the ground and contained the actions of these so-called police officers is pathetic and inexcusable. There aboslutely needs to be a federal overhaul of police brutality and misconduct. It's time for the thin blue line to be permanently disbanded.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 2:20 PM Me wrote ...

I bet this guy wishes he had gotten a job years ago instead of being a burden to society. Thank you Fresno police for making this guy pay for his free ride...Get a job and then I'll give you rights but if you can't contribute to society then I don't care what happens to you....cold I know but it is what it is!

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 2:06 PM Kim wrote ...

Looking past the inexcusable actions of the arresting officers, this is the most poorly written article I have read this week. Please proofread your content before posting online.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 1:56 PM Coastal girl wrote ...

Gosh, I'm sorry I moved away from Fresno! Hah. But really, what is going through these cops minds, it looked like they we're worried about being seen beating this guy, lookin around first, then punchin him. Poor guy. The video didn't show him resisting arrest, unless he just said "no, I don't wanna be arrested", but who wouldn't say that? He probably pulled the officers badge off, when trying to hold on to something to avoid being knocked down by these "thugs". Jerry Dyer, shame on you!!!

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 1:51 PM NO TOWN wrote ...

CANT TRUST ANYONE THESE DAYS!OF COURSE THERE IS TWO STORYS TO WHAT HAPPENED,BUT COME ON YOU JUST PUT TO GETHER WHAT HAPPEN AND LOOK AT THE VIDEO! PICTURE SAYS A THOUANDS WORDS!WELL A VIDEO IS PRICE LESS! POLICE BRUTALITY FACE IT!!!!!! JUSTICE NEEDS TO BE SERVED!

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 1:24 PM Tom wrote ...

These officers did nothing wrong. They are the authority here and you must cooperate with their commands when being detained. Any resistance carries consequences. Whether that be a fist to head or taser shot to the sternum. It is the officer's first responsibility to protect himself from any uncooperative individual and subdue the suspect. Maybe the homeless man will think twice about resisting arrest the next time.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 1:17 PM sandra lopez wrote ...

Fresno needs a police chief that knows what he is doing , how can you defend these cowards beating on a homeless man,stop the lame excuses for these lazy cops they do it becuase they know that they can get away with it,,, get to work jerry or give the job to someone that can do it.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 1:12 PM Erika wrote ...

I understand about fairness and how you have to be neutral during an investigation. There is no excuse for beating a person who is in handcuffs and the man is homeless for God Sakes. I hope man who has nothing to his name but a beating to his face ends up winning a law suit and gets off the streets into a home all because of the two officers who blindly did not care about following rules. No Excuse!

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 1:02 PM charlie wrote ...

What a surprise, have these cops ever heard of pepper spray? I'm sure the Fresno P.D. equips their officers with pepper spray. Does this cop realizeost homeless people have Hepatitis and H.I.V.? This guy is punching him in the face w/no gloves to boot. The guy is already face down, instead of punching him, try to get his arms behind his back Einstein...good police work.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 1:01 PM citizen wrote ...

police work can be violent and aggressive, it is not meant for citizens to see, everyone is up in arms about this video, but if this man was attacking your kids u would be okay with any force necessary to neutralize the threat. but if someone attacks the police it's okay. what kind of thinking is that.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 12:39 PM Anonymous City Worker wrote ...

Let's hope the new mayor takes note of this continual and very disturbing practice by the FPD which IS condoned by it's own Chief and supported by his Captains on down.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 12:34 PM unknown wrote ...

No one knows exactly what happened so I think everyone should keep their mouth shut. Assumptions are always wrong. When people strike or attack officers, people don't defend them or stand up for them very often, only citizens. Officers have to deal with more than anyone realizes. Maybe these officers need to deal with issues before they continue on their career path and be reprimanded.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 11:22 AM Willard Lee wrote ...

Those 2 coward cops, beat that homeless man just like gangsters would savagely beat a man, they are a stink to the, Fresno Police Department.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 10:19 AM heckandarn wrote ...

This stuff is getting old. Dyer needs to look for work!

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 10:12 AM Hugh Martin wrote ...

There is no excuse for type of brutality. Both officers involved should face felony assault charges.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 9:26 AM Chan wrote ...

The police continue to beat this homeless man even after he is on the ground face down. There is no excuse that makes this reasonable. So what if he took out a pen? I have taken out a pen many times, I was not aware that was some sort of threat. Where I live, many homeless are mentally ill and are struggling with more than poverty. To make them the target of abuse at the hands of the foot soldiers of our executive branch of government is reprehensible.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 9:24 AM Al wrote ...

When an individual decides to place themselves above others, as a policeman, they must be able to withstand verbal abuse and physical resistance- particularly that of people who are panicked, without their faculties, impaired, etc.- without resorting to retaliation. In the video we see an elderly man, whose movement is limited and easily subdued. All resources are clearly on the side of the policemen. We see incompetance and abuse of power. Given Dyer's comments, he should be fired and barred.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 9:21 AM Lynn wrote ...

I live in Indiana, just saw the video on the Today show. Then I heard the police chief speak. I want to say to that police chief "NOTHING ON GODS GREEN EARTH WOULD EVER JUSTIFY HITTING A HOMELESS MAN MULTIPLE TIMES IN THE FACE WHEN HE IS DOWN" !!!!!! "EVER" I THINK THE POLICE CHIEF NEEDS TO BE INVESTIGATED AS WELL!!!!

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 9:10 AM Anonymous wrote ...

It is clear from viewing the video that this officer was using excessive force. The man (Beaty) was restrained by both officers, while the one office is repeatedly punching him in the face. This is police brutality, pure and simple. This officer should be jailed.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 9:08 AM William wrote ...

Police Brutality is out of control! This is like when the Metropolitan Airport Police beat up the girl at Reagan National Airport. You don't beat up people. If you want to arrest them, there is a humane way to do it. By the police chief defending their actions, it just promotes other police beating up people who cannot defend themselves. There needs to be a federal overhaul of police brutality because it is obvious police chief's just cover up or make lame excuses for bad cops.

Wednesday, Feb 11 at 4:33 AM secret wrote ...

no excuse what so ever

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

KSEE 24 NEWS and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More Good Stuff

Advertisement
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
Icon
Current Temp 76.0 °F
Mostly Cloudy
Wind : Calm
Humidity : 36 %
Pressure : 1017.1 mb
More Weather

On Demand

Stock Quotes

What's On TonightFull Schedule

8:00
Mercy
9:00
Law & Order: Special
10:00
Law & Order: Special
Local Business Dir

Valley Viewpoint Poll

What is your best hangover remedy?

  • 'Hair of the dog'
  • Gatorade
  • Lots of water
  • Greasy food
  • Aspirin/Ibuprofen
  • Coffee/tea