EXCLUSIVE: Police Accusations

Tools

By Carolyn Bruck

Wednesday, through a department spokesperson, Fresno Police Chief Jerry Dyer refused to comment on allegations he's condoned a culture of violence within the force.

Dyer declined to discuss accusations made by a member of his own force, that he had a hand in manipulating the outcome of internal affairs investigations.

But, attorneys pushing a lawsuit against the chief and the department hope to show that Dyer's own misconduct set a tone for the department.

In a February 26th deposition obtained exclusively by KSEE 24 News, Dyer admitted he violated police procedure in the past.

The civil rights lawsuit claims Dyer's misconduct opened the door for other officers to behave outside of policy.

The accusations stem from a March 2005 incident involving current Fresno Police Sergeant Michael Manfredi and former officer Marcus Tafoya who are also named as defendants in the lawsuit.

During a welcome home party for Ralph Rendon, a Marine who had served in Iraq, 10 plaintiffs claim they were assaulted by Sgt. Manfredi and Officer Tafoya.

The other Fresno police officers on scene the night of the alleged misconduct have been questioned.

The deposition of at least one officer asserts reports with differing accounts of what occurred the night of the alleged assaults were written.

Yet still, it was stated in open court, Manfredi and Tafoya were cleared of any wrong doing after the first internal affairs investigation.

After hearing the testimony of all parties thus far, plaintiff’s attorney, Peter Kapetan questioned the legitimacy of internal affairs investigations.

Kapetan said, “We’ve had officers testify that internal affairs investigations were being manipulated by the department to have a desired outcome.”

Officers alleged in their depositions after reporting apparent violations of police procedure they suffered retaliation.

One officer said he was called a “rat” by Sgt. Manfredi who was his superior at the time.

When attorney’s asked why the officer did not contact Manfredi’s supervisors, the officer said he knew “nothing would change” because that type of behavior was “the status quo in the department.”

The officer then said blowing the whistle on a supervisor who “knows a lot of people” would be a “losing battle.”

Sergeant Manfredi’s alleges in his deposition that he had knowledge police personnel improperly influenced the outcome of internal affairs investigations to exonerate guilty officers.

Manfredi refused to give specific details during his deposition.

At a court hearing Tuesday, Manfredi was ordered to reveal names and specific details to support his allegations.

Peter Kapetan said what began as an investigation into a 4 year old excessive force claim, could end up revealing a much greater violation.

“Our lawsuit alleges the Chief actively knew about these things and actively, not necessarily participated, but encouraged this type of conduct by officers”, Kapetan said.

Click on the link to see Carolyn Bruck’s exclusive report.

Tuesday, Apr 7 at 10:59 PM collieterrier wrote ...

P Have you ever worked anywhere,that management does not lie.They all lie.This is every where.

Tuesday, Apr 7 at 11:25 AM just wondering wrote ...

Wineville's name was changed to Mira Loma (Changeling)after police corruption was brought to light. WHAT WILL FRESNO'S NEW NAME BE?

Tuesday, Apr 7 at 11:20 AM i know dyer wrote ...

His past steroid use and rages have left permanent psychological damage. He has always been violent and now uses that church to cover up his crimes. That church is his sheep's clothing.

Sunday, Apr 5 at 7:08 PM J wrote ...

Nothing adds up in this case and I dont belive the cops for a second. Dyer changed his story 4 times now to what happened. police are always the first to get on the scene so how can you belive what they say. oh wait they have a badge so they are right B.S. all the facts from the cops dont add up at all and there stories are not consistent you people need to pay better attention. you can through some stuff out cause of the news but you cant throughout dyers 4 diffrent stories!!!!!!

Sunday, Apr 5 at 12:36 AM sammy wrote ...

Tina ! b honest , you've had a drink or 2 at dinner , you drove , u could've killed smeone! but u should'nt b executed 4 it! & yeah , they put their lifes on the line every day , but it don't give'em the right to take 1! Our military risk theirs by far , but you don't see them coming home beating & killing people!2 wrongs don't make it right! Jerry Dyre ! Ur corrupt ! & you may get away with these killings & beating here! but you'll still have 2 answer to god 1 day!

Saturday, Apr 4 at 12:21 PM JG wrote ...

continued: Ohh I forgot to add, In reality those of you who blast the Fresno Police or any other Law enforcement agency for that matter are those of you who do not have a job, and have been in and out of prison and or county jail. If you can not follow the laws of the land then don't be surprised when the Police come after you. And when a cop dies we all suffer.I dont think I want to run into a burning fire or into a gun battle.let's give credit where credit is due.DYER you are DOING aGREAT JOB

Saturday, Apr 4 at 12:07 PM JG wrote ...

You all who blast the Police department need to get a life. A Police Officer is also a human being. They put their lives on the line everyday. However you come into your own conclusions without knowing all the facts. Let's see who you call when burglars break into your house or vehicle taking your personal property which you work so hard to obtain. Not to mention a rapist who might come into your house or stalk you after you leave work. Who are you going to call? .. Think about it.. Thank u FPD

Saturday, Apr 4 at 10:52 AM RC wrote ...

:continued: It was only then that he noticed I had my son in His CARSEAT. The officer then says"Whos Baby Is THat"? Then points at the diaper bag and says "whos purse is that"? after I answered him .The officer takes my license runs it, then returns, and informs me of a warrant in another state for me!(Ive never left California)It Turns out he had{ Misread My License Number!}he returned my license and drove away!Those are the facts.who gives them the right to Bully Families,CHildren! at GUNPOINT

Saturday, Apr 4 at 10:30 AM RC wrote ...

J, I absolutely agree.Recently whilst driving on first and clinton,I was pulled over by a Fresno P.D. officer (although I am current the registration sticker showing the Month on my plates was stolen)with my infant son in the car the officer demanded all the usual documents and as I leaned over to open the glovebox he said"hey! why you reaching"?He kind of toched me on the elbow with hie left hand and in his right he had his pistol drawn and pointed towards my torso!

Saturday, Apr 4 at 1:18 AM E C's Mom wrote ...

J - so if 14 times is a little much, is that the argument here? That he was shot 14 times, when it should have only been once? If he had been shot once - and was killed would everyone still be pointing fingers rather than admitting that this kid made a huge mistake? Nobody has said he was a bad kid, or even that he deserved to die - but he made a deadly decision that night by carrying a gun while completely drunk and then shooting at anyone, let alone police. PERIOD.

Friday, Apr 3 at 11:01 AM p wrote ...

4 times in the back also.. they also could have reloaded... how many bullets in one clip? 35 rounds shot at him... i am tired of all this 'what if'.. what if the cops didn't shoot? maybe nothing would of happened.. what if the cops are lying? if this county went by 'what if' we all would be in trouble.. we should only worry about now... what if i get hit walking down the street.. then i would just be stuck in my house...

Friday, Apr 3 at 3:16 AM J wrote ...

tina- 14 shots were removed from him. thats a little much.

Friday, Apr 3 at 2:43 AM TINA wrote ...

You know i feel sorry for what happen but he was a grown man who made choose to get in a car and drive knowing he was drunk and high how many people could he have killed trying to get home you want to get mad at the police well the story could have a different out come if he had killed a family trying to get home, so some of you need to think about how mad you are at the police. They risk there life every day trying to the right thing the mess up yeah but how many have died doing it.

Friday, Apr 3 at 12:42 AM ... wrote ...

This is such a dumb accusation with no evidence to back it up.Another way 24 is trying to get people to by into more lies. You guys have no shame and dont care who you hurt to get a story out.

Friday, Apr 3 at 12:07 AM J wrote ...

I am trying not to be heartless but in our current econmic state, we have to look at the overall people picture. can we really afford to be doing something like that???? I care more about the state as a whole than a few people. I am sorry. I just see it diffrently.....

Friday, Apr 3 at 12:05 AM J wrote ...

this is pathetic- heartless as it may seem its the truth. for a state that deals in such high dollars cant afford to spend tax payer money on this. then we get another tax hike. am I sorry they died? yes I am. but with all the public tax dollars going to that come on now.... I dont work 5-6 days a week to see my taxed checks go to that you and I know NOT 1 PERSON DESERVES AN ELABRENT FUNERAL LIKE THAT UNLESS IT COMES FROM A PERSONAL POCKET! I would love to see the budget on that.

Thursday, Apr 2 at 8:57 PM Krista wrote ...

Way to go Fresno PD..... Your lead by Pyshco

Thursday, Apr 2 at 8:48 PM this is pathetic wrote ...

First off J, you should be ashamed of yourself, how much tax dollars were spent on their funeral? Heartless! I think you are living in the wrong state, the cost of their funeral should be the least of your tax woes! And I also noticed how KSEE 24 and KFSN 30 have not done an update on the toxicology results, they just want to print garbage on the FPD, pathetic!

Thursday, Apr 2 at 6:55 PM p wrote ...

To yea right: its called the Pareto principle.. surveys.. you ask all your friends and see how many cops were nice during a stop (hi, how are you today? nice weather we having)and how many were cold (license, registration, here's ur ticket, deal wit it in court). if you want your burger from MC'Ds fast, 20% is quality and 80% is service. Sounds like someone doesn't have a bachelor's degree.. =P

Thursday, Apr 2 at 6:35 PM Miro Spiro wrote ...

Enough is enough. Get the auditor and give him expedicious investigative authority. If you had any investigative media or reporters in this town worth their salt, this situation would never have gotten this far. Don't tell me anything makes any sense on either side of all these department issues. It just doesn't.

Thursday, Apr 2 at 6:34 PM yea right wrote ...

HEy P were is your research to back up such a far fetched concept. That has to be one of the dummest things i have heard all year!!!!

Thursday, Apr 2 at 6:20 PM p wrote ...

yea, that's what i said... if i had to go to a funeral, i couldn't take my company's car.. i had to drive my own, use my gas, and take personal time from work.. how many of them did that?? its very hard to trust police. i believe in the 80/20 rule. Out 10 cops you meet, 8 are bad (jerks) and 2 are good. 80% of the force will lie and 20% will tell the truth... its a concept everywhere. Its fact!

Thursday, Apr 2 at 6:14 PM J F off wrote ...

J, wasted tax dollars. Go to city hall and ask 4 a refund. ill meet u there and give u the 1 dollar of your money and wipe it... just for you...

Thursday, Apr 2 at 6:09 PM CH 24's new name "Fresno Enquirer" wrote ...

Wow... in the Chief's career he admitted that he had violated policy... HE would not be human or lying if he said he didn't, he is human. The question asked to the chief was general- "While on-duty have you ever violated policy?"... I see CH24 doesn't want to update the story on how DRUNK the suspect was in the police shooting, but ready to dig up dirt on an old incident. 1 cop was fired and looks like the Sergant Manfrede is trying to save his career and get immunity by making allegations.

Thursday, Apr 2 at 5:50 PM J wrote ...

This is why Fresno PD cannot be trusted every individual must watch there backs. they have this supposed brotherhood where they do what they can to protect each other even if they are in the wrong. How much tax dollars were wasted on the oakland funeral. over 500 police crusiers not including motorcycles, the choppers used to fly in other departments there and back HOW MUCH TAX MONEY WENT TO THIS?????? WE TAX PAYERS PAY TO MUCH???? since when is public safety a price gouge.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

KSEE 24 NEWS and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More Good Stuff

Advertisement
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.
Icon
Current Temp 52.0 °F
Fair
Wind : Calm
Humidity : 69 %
Pressure : 1024.7 mb
More Weather

On Demand

Stock Quotes

What's On TonightFull Schedule

8:00
Biggest Loser
10:00
Parenthood
Local Business Dir

Valley Viewpoint Poll

What do you consider the most dangerous food?

  • Hot dogs
  • Peanuts
  • Leafy greens
  • Tuna
  • Mushrooms
  • Coffee